Cordelia
Really Really Experienced
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2001
- Posts
- 475
Re: Re: And one's I thought needed mention...
I was referring to a question I asked on another thread. I am sure it got lost in the other posts.
I will copy it here for you.
That was it. I am merely curious, as I am newer to poetry critique.
I was making no comment about the author, merely encouraging people to ignore who wrote it and read the poem itself. I enjoyed it.
And thank you for your comments on my writing. I am a mathematician by education and an accountant by profession, so numbers fascinate me as well. Writing is merely a great way for me to exercise the right side of my brain.
Regards,
Cordelia
Senna Jawa said:Cordelia, I think highly about your poetry and about your potential. I never meant to "ignore" you. I am much less active on the forum than one would infere from the flames. Please ask your questions now and I'll do my best to answer them.
I was referring to a question I asked on another thread. I am sure it got lost in the other posts.
I will copy it here for you.
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Senna Jawa
In particular a lot of time is wasted on "discussing" and praising poor poems.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I am posing a serious question here. And it is only a question. I don't want to have barbs thrown at me because of it.
Is it possible, Senna, that poems you consider poor may be considered good by others? Or is it possible that your definition of poetry is merely one of many?
I know we should post our opinions with reasons why we feel the poem is bad or good, or why certain elements work or don't work. But in the end, it is all opinion. And I always take comments about my poetry (justified or not), as opinion.
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Senna Jawa
When you plan exciting trips, you should discuss the interesting roads, paths and directions and not the worthless, hopeless dead ends. Learning from mistakes has only a very limited potential, especially when mistakes are not acknowledged, not even recognized.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Again, I agree with you here. I just feel that people see interesting things in hopeless dead-ends as well as on scenic thru-ways. Is it possible to nod to someone else's opinion, then present your own as an alternative? And I address this to everyone, not just Senna.
Just asking...
Cordelia
That was it. I am merely curious, as I am newer to poetry critique.
That's a nice attitude toward poetry, objective, even if I hear a serious doubt about the author as a person.
I was making no comment about the author, merely encouraging people to ignore who wrote it and read the poem itself. I enjoyed it.
And thank you for your comments on my writing. I am a mathematician by education and an accountant by profession, so numbers fascinate me as well. Writing is merely a great way for me to exercise the right side of my brain.
Regards,
Cordelia
We were talking in chat here, and I offered to write a sonnet on the spot on a topic of his choosing. Homer, swell guy that he is lol, said write one on what to wear in a state of nothingness. So love it or hate it, it's um his fault. Yeah, his fault, that's the ticket. 
!