"To keep the review thread clean..."

Status
Not open for further replies.
vampiredust said:
I'm taking a different approach with my Sunday review and comments. I will praise when needed and will be more honest in feedback. A lot more honest.


good for you.

and for everyone, i think.

speaking for myself, the reviews have become quite like an endless stream of billboards along a highway.

it will be refreshing to see poetry discussed, rather than advertised.

:rose:
 
TheRainMan said:
good for you.

and for everyone, i think.

speaking for myself, the reviews have become quite like an endless stream of billboards along a highway.

it will be refreshing to see poetry discussed, rather than advertised.

:rose:


i hope mine don't come across to everyone else in that way.

:rose:
 
wildsweetone said:
i hope mine don't come across to everyone else in that way.

:rose:

Not at all. Meant to thank you for the mention and the capitalization criticism, I didn't even notice the screwed up scheme I started until you pointed it out :)
 
wildsweetone said:
i hope mine don't come across to everyone else in that way.

:rose:

to tell you the truth, i stopped reading the reviews some time ago . . . because i could get that driving on the turnpike and get somewhere at the same time.

i just looked at the thread for the first time in a while . . .

no, your recent reviews do not come off as advertisement.

they are VERY well-done.

kudos to you, Kiwi. :)

it's reviews like those, and decisions like Christian's, that will turn the link to that thread back into one worth clicking on.

:rose:
 
darkerdreamer said:
Not at all. Meant to thank you for the mention and the capitalization criticism, I didn't even notice the screwed up scheme I started until you pointed it out :)


glad my thoughts were helpful darkerdreamer. :)


thanks TRM. maybe you should do some reviewing too.

:rose:
 
TheRainMan said:
i'd get tar and feathered,

and run out of town on a rail.

:rose:
LOL... It's comments like these that should put you onto Jenn's (HotKittySpank)'s challenge thread. G'wan, write a cliche poem about cliches. :) You know you wahn-nah.
 
wildsweetone said:
i hope mine don't come across to everyone else in that way.

:rose:
I read your reviews and no, you don't write simple advertisements. I admire you (and all of you) for the amount of work you do to give a well thought out critique rather than a straightforward glowing recommendation.

It's hard, time-consuming and thankless work sometimes but as you, WSO, say, writing the reviews carries its own reward of learning something more about poetry.

Kudos to all of you who persevere in the daily review production.

:rose:
 
Thanks!!

"vampiredust" Thank you for the mention in todays "New Poems Review". Your comments and being noted here mean a lot to Me.
 
TheRainMan said:
to tell you the truth, i stopped reading the reviews some time ago . . . because i could get that driving on the turnpike and get somewhere at the same time.

i just looked at the thread for the first time in a while . . .

no, your recent reviews do not come off as advertisement.

they are VERY well-done.

kudos to you, Kiwi. :)

it's reviews like those, and decisions like Christian's, that will turn the link to that thread back into one worth clicking on.

:rose:


DAMN YOU

I was hoping for MNS in blinking lights :rolleyes:

:rose:
 
WickedEve said:
<snip>Edit: Okay, I really did check way too early. Now there are plenty of poems. I'll start reading and return later. ;)
Wow! There are a LOT of poems posted today Evie. I think they all heard you were back doing reviews and wanted you to read them. A magenta WE should be a new Lit list indicator, signifying your porny approval. :)
 
WickedEve said:
Thought I was finished but found some good poetry by Fallenfromgrace
There are three new ones from this poet.
Surprisingly (for me) I like My Ashes best. I enjoyed the repetition of "My ashes go To India soon."

Also, check out Silence and Smoke
Thank you for the mention :rose: it was a tough decision for me to post My Ashes in the first place, and so i appreciate the mention and review very very much. :rose:
 
Hey, Eve, thanks for mentioning "deep" in your review. I must object, though, to your characterization of it as a "tit poem." I don't write "tit poems"--I write "breast poems." You know, classy.

Tit poems are below me. Usually. Though above is nice too. :rolleyes:
 
Tzara said:
Hey, Eve, thanks for mentioning "deep" in your review. I must object, though, to your characterization of it as a "tit poem." I don't write "tit poems"--I write "breast poems." You know, classy.

Tit poems are below me. Usually. Though above is nice too. :rolleyes:

Hey, "tit" can be poetic, too!

...right?

(note to self: don't use the word "tit" in poems. Gazongas... maybe.)
 
Tzara said:
Hey, Eve, thanks for mentioning "deep" in your review. I must object, though, to your characterization of it as a "tit poem." I don't write "tit poems"--I write "breast poems." You know, classy.

Tit poems are below me. Usually. Though above is nice too. :rolleyes:
I thought you might like that review. :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top