Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ally C said:
It seems to be a 'cultural' thang. Look on the bright side, at least they haven't been sidelined by the promise of a "third way"©.
The third way being "we do whatever George tells us to."
 
vetteman said:
It's more fundamnetal than that to me, I question your authority and judgement for doing it in the first place. You want to impose those strictures here let's vote on it.

So you want to live in a law abiding society as long as that doesn't infringe on your so called liberties?

Liberties and rights end when your right to do something harms someone else.

As I said, your argument isn't holding weight. And you totally lost me with the voting request.
 
vetteman said:
Such a time machine will no doubt find our progeny enslaved, lamenting our lack of courage to face down those who would be our masters.

Two competing ways to interpret this reply:

1) It hints of an attitude that to non American observers is infected with a wholly unjustifiable paranoia. Let's put the wagons in a circle and build a fort around them just in case. Cue a ten thousand post thread about theories of human nature, the primacy of the USA, liberty, ass kicking and unspeakable monsters under the bed.

2) There is already a lack of courage when it comes to facing down your masters. Sure, you can vote them out, but when you see the jokers who get elected (and re-elected) the mind boggles. Cue a two word post loaded with equally irrational and mis-directed anger.

Don't take it personally. :)
 
vetteman said:
I know I lost you, that's what worries me. Your misundertanding of the function of our government amazes me. It was founded to secure the rights and private property of it's people, not impose the will of the rest of the world on it's citizens. This is not to say it hasn't been grossly in it's duty.

LOL, I think you're the one who is lost here. By mandating clean air and water and putting in pollution controls etc. the government is securing my rights. What you seem to not like is that you have to spend a little more of your money over the health of our people (especially our children) and that worries me.
 
The function of your government

vetteman said:
It was founded to secure the rights and private property of it's people, not impose the will of the rest of the world on it's citizens. This is not to say it hasn't been grossly in it's duty.

That's all very noble but if you were to flesh out the potential meanings of "rights and private property" (no I'm not being obtuse), then I think you'd end up with one god-awful unmanageable shambles. The ideal is praiseworthy, but the practicalities are reducable to a bureaucrat's wet dream.

This thing about the imposition of the rest of the world's will ... I know what you mean, but just don't get how you can believe that. Unless you want to exist in a vacuum and somehow shun the idea and effects of globalisation (no need to go into detail here) then there will always have to be some sort of concessions. Your empire is not facing oblivion, this is not the thin end of the wedge.
 
zipman said:
LOL, I think you're the one who is lost here. By mandating clean air and water and putting in pollution controls etc. the government is securing my rights. What you seem to not like is that you have to spend a little more of your money over the health of our people (especially our children) and that worries me.
I've never really understood the perspective that I have to breathe shit and filter my water just so someone's "right" to cheap fuel isn't infringed.
 
vetteman said:
I'm a man of few words, I don't need ten thousand words to explain my view of things, it being a bit parochial. If you want to improve the world start bringing everyone else up to our existing standards before you institute any further change here.

The word thing was just from experience of all the (usually closet) posters who suddenly arrive on the scene throwing predictable lines that cover all the usual bases. However, there'd be no point in anyone typing anything any more if we all had the same outlook.

I hear what you're saying, but deny any knowledge of instituting change on your side of the pond. "I did not have institutional changes with that nation". So there. :D
 
vetteman said:
Are you breathing shit Pereg? Do you have to filter your water? Fuck, move into town for Christ's sake. Ever been to Mexico City?
Yup, and so is the rest of the world. See: acid rain, smog, etc.

Nope. Been to Guatemala City, though.

I don't see "It's worse elsewhere" as an argument not to clean up my own backyard.
 
vetteman said:
I'm a good taxpayer Zip, I've paid them every cent they ever said I owed them, despite haviing seen many of their collectivist plans turn into boondoggles.

I've paid for my own health care for most of my life and now that its a right of entitlement, I have yet to see a refund. I guess some folks are more equal than others. I am all for clean air and pollution controls, I just happen to think that they ought to apply to everyone else before more of them are applied here.
Do you apply the same standard to your own behavior? Do you figure it's okay to steal because somewhere in the word, someone is getting raped? Or do you behave the best way you possibly can because it's the right thing to do, regardless of what everyone else is doing?
 
Peregrinator said:
Yup, and so is the rest of the world. See: acid rain, smog, etc.

Nope. Been to Guatemala City, though.

I don't see "It's worse elsewhere" as an argument not to clean up my own backyard.
It's just another variation on the wingnut "but they do it too" refrain. I expect A_J along any minute blaming Clinton.
 
SeanH said:
It's just another variation on the wingnut "but they do it too" refrain. I expect A_J along any minute blaming Clinton.
Sometimes it seems that way. I also note that the same people who accuse Al Gore of "spreading hysteria" are more or less constantly telling me there will be an international financial disaster if we reduce carbon emissions. I've pointed out a few times lately that no one went bankrupt over catalytic converters or CFC bans.
 
vetteman said:
Well I've never been put in jail, I don't have a police record, and I've been around a lot longer than you, what do you think?
I think either you're good at getting away with stuff, or you're a decent, law-abiding guy who makes good ethical decisions. I choose the latter. Given that, what's wrong with holding the country/energy corporations to the same standards? Why shouldn't we do the best job we can?
 
This 'debate' has certainly taken some interesting turns.

With the general distrust of politicians and the source or motives of studies, I think it might be more beneficial not to mention effective for everyone if we engaged in smaller steps and efforts to educate and lead by example (think globally - act locally) than it is to try to mandate, force and bully others (especially half way around the world) into behaving the way you want them to or think they should.
 
vetteman said:
I do, since it's the "elsewhere" trying to foist their impossible standards, standards they can't meet themselves, on us.
Who's doing that? What "impossible" standards? Are those same people trying to make changes in their own countries as well?
 
Peregrinator said:
I think either you're good at getting away with stuff, or you're a decent, law-abiding guy who makes good ethical decisions. I choose the latter. Given that, what's wrong with holding the country/energy corporations to the same standards? Why shouldn't we do the best job we can?

I happen to agree with much of this. I gather Vette is a pretty good man in his actions and decisions. I also think there is value and merit in educating the public AND industry to look into ways to reduce our impact on the environment. This is what I meant by education and 'steps' towards lower impact.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top