Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
vetteman said:
They tried to foist the Kyoto Accords on us, not a single Senator voted for it. I read this morning that EU countries can't meet it's standards.
Britain has met and exceeded them. And without our economy crashing. Fancy that.
 
vetteman said:
They tried to foist the Kyoto Accords on us, not a single Senator voted for it. I read this morning that EU countries can't meet it's standards.
Who did?

Oddly enough, many US cities and states have resolved to meet or exceed Kyoto standards. In fact, your own California is leading the charge. You bankrupt yet?
 
vetteman said:
I think we are doing the best we can, but let's have a long reasoned national debate before we re-order society and potentially cripple industry. That's all I ask.
I don't think we're doing nearly the best we can yet.

It's been debated since around 1970 or so.
 
Peregrinator said:
Impossible. You're all going to starve to death soon.
It would make a change from the epidemic of obesity that seems to be overrunning our kids.
 
dcraz said:
I happen to agree with much of this. I gather Vette is a pretty good man in his actions and decisions. I also think there is value and merit in educating the public AND industry to look into ways to reduce our impact on the environment. This is what I meant by education and 'steps' towards lower impact.
I'm quite sure that Vette is a standup guy. Nearly a Boy Scout, in fact, except that he's a pervert.

Those initiatives are ongoing, and have been for many years; I agree with you. The biggest obstacle to them, it seems to me, is the energy cartel with its constant obfuscating and misinformation. The parallel to tobacco is striking.
 
SeanH said:
It would make a change from the epidemic of obesity that seems to be overrunning our kids.
You people need a serious war again. Do you no end of good.
 
Peregrinator said:
You people need a serious war again. Do you no end of good.
I don't think Tony could drag us into another one. No matter what George wants to do in Iran.
 
Peregrinator said:
I don't think we're doing nearly the best we can yet.

It's been debated since around 1970 or so.

Perhaps we could do better. But much of the debate infers we have done nothing. Or worse yet, strive to do more harm in the future than we are today in the pursuit of money above all else. This simply is not true.

We have cleaned up emissions in autos and industry, changed freon mixtures, banned CFCs, and much more. To suggest we do nothing is insincere. Not enough? That is for each to decide. I have no doubt we will do better in the future. Particularly as attitudes change. And people begin living their beliefs (the original thread topic). But Gore is hardly the only one guilty of this. The fact that he is so high profile, unfortunately weakens the strength of his message. But one has to look no further than next door in most cases to see people that say one thing and live another...
 
SeanH said:
I don't think Tony could drag us into another one. No matter what George wants to do in Iran.
Yeah, you need your own Pearl Harbor. Where are the Germans to help you man up again?
 
dcraz said:
Perhaps we could do better. But much of the debate infers we have done nothing. Or worse yet, strive to do more harm in the future than we are today in the pursuit of money above all else. This simply is not true.

We have cleaned up emissions in autos and industry, changed freon mixtures, banned CFCs, and much more. To suggest we do nothing is insincere. Not enough? That is for each to decide. I have no doubt we will do better in the future. Particularly as attitudes change. And people begin living their beliefs (the original thread topic). But Gore is hardly the only one guilty of this. The fact that he is so high profile, unfortunately weakens the strength of his message. But one has to look no further than next door in most cases to see people that say one thing and live another...
Sure. I don't think too many people would purposely imply that we have done nothing.

I think the people who take shots at Gore for using airplanes are ridiculous, personally. No one on the planet has done more to reduce emissions than he has.

And of course I agree about the cognitive dissonance. It's the human condition. I think it's why people are so quick to advocate for regulation; we see how badly things get fucked up when there isn't any "government interference."
 
Peregrinator said:
I'm quite sure that Vette is a standup guy. Nearly a Boy Scout, in fact, except that he's a pervert.

Those initiatives are ongoing, and have been for many years; I agree with you. The biggest obstacle to them, it seems to me, is the energy cartel with its constant obfuscating and misinformation. The parallel to tobacco is striking.

The history of misdirection in the tobacco industry is legendary and continues to grow each day. Unfortunately. And I agree that the lobbying efforts of the energy companies draw striking and ugly parallels.

What concerns me about the current Global Warming debate is the same concerns I have for so many high emotion and often irrational debates (on both sides). The hysteria and passion of those leading the charge lessons the penetration of the message.
 
dcraz said:
The history of misdirection in the tobacco industry is legendary and continues to grow each day. Unfortunately. And I agree that the lobbying efforts of the energy companies draw striking and ugly parallels.

What concerns me about the current Global Warming debate is the same concerns I have for so many high emotion and often irrational debates (on both sides). The hysteria and passion of those leading the charge lessons the penetration of the message.
I agree %100. I have this discussion with my wife all the time. (She works on gw issues for a local enviro.) The shrill, hysterical message seems to me to do as much damage as it does good. It's the same on the other side; the people who screamed at me that CFC bans and catalytic converters would bankrupt the world are just as dumb-sounding to me. Fact is, even with many, many cities meeting or exceeding Kyoto standards, our economy is quite robust.
 
Peregrinator said:
Crosstalk. Sean means they've met emissions standards; your link is about temperatures.
It's a trick he learned from Ishtard, when someone blows your argument apart with facts, change the argument.
 
SeanH said:
It's a trick he learned from Ishtard, when someone blows your argument apart with facts, change the argument.
I don't know. I don't see Vette as that kind of disputant.
 
Peregrinator said:
I agree %100. I have this discussion with my wife all the time. (She works on gw issues for a local enviro.) The shrill, hysterical message seems to me to do as much damage as it does good. It's the same on the other side; the people who screamed at me that CFC bans and catalytic converters would bankrupt the world are just as dumb-sounding to me. Fact is, even with many, many cities meeting or exceeding Kyoto standards, our economy is quite robust.

Perg, you and I have had a similiar discussion about hardcore animal rights activists and the harm they do to their own cause. The constant doomsaying and "in your face" attacks tend to drive away the mainstream and make their cause less affective.

As to Gore, I think the people who are laughing at him and calling him a hypocrite are doing it for the same reason that people attack religous figures who fall from grace. Nobody likes being preached to only to find out the preacher is less than perfect.

One more point...I am firm believer in the market/capitalism but anyone that believes business will do things on their own, that cost money and don't do anything for the bottom line are delusional. Yes, you can find instances of industry doing "good", but for the most part, without government regulation, industry will put it's profits before the public good.
 
Peregrinator said:
Sure. I don't think too many people would purposely imply that we have done nothing.

I think the people who take shots at Gore for using airplanes are ridiculous, personally. No one on the planet has done more to reduce emissions than he has.

And of course I agree about the cognitive dissonance. It's the human condition. I think it's why people are so quick to advocate for regulation; we see how badly things get fucked up when there isn't any "government interference."

Whether they 'purposely imply' that we have done nothing or so, many are quick to suggest we are all the spawn of Satan for not doing everything 'they' believe we should. And more. All I'm asking for is a little balance and temper in the tone. If possible.

I have no doubt that Gore believes the message he is spreading. And I do not disagree that he has single handedly done much. More than maybe any other. But I would stop FAR short of suggesting that he has personally done more to reduce emissions than anyone else on the planet.

Regulation can work. When implemented in steps. Moderation and transition allows industry and the public to adapt to new technologies, price impacts, and to work out the kinks of such stepped regulations. Fast, extreme, knee jerk reactions and punitive or abusive regulation does no one any good. Neither the industry regulated or the public impacted by the results of such regulation.

What would be far better, IMO, would be for the public and the world at large to put their money and inconveniences where their mouths are in seeing these transitions through. Would these environmentalists buy electricity from a 'green' power generator if it cost a little more thana 'dirty' provider? Would the world pay more for the same goods that were manufactured in a 'clean' country vs. cheaper goods manufactured in a 'dirty' country? Look no further than child labor laws and local standards of living for various industries moving their shops to Asia to see how difficult it is for the average person to practice what they preach.
 
dcraz said:
Look no further than child labor laws and local standards of living for various industries moving their shops to Asia to see how difficult it is for the average person to practice what they preach.
A lot of people are doing precisely that. The growth of organic and fair trade products, the exponential growth in solar panels and micro generation turbines, the move to energy saving appliances, to name just a few.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top