Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
dcraz said:
Surely you are not suggesting that one has to be poor or a liberal democrat to be environmentally friendly... Or that to be environmentally friendly is to be the violent target of republicans... Are you? :rolleyes:

Soy-tun-lee not! I made a light-hearted and very general reply to a specific person about a randomly chosen possibility. It was very much in the spirit of this thread ... well maybe 'cept the 'light-hearted' bit. ;)
 
This sounds like something SeanH could endorse:
"The proposed limits on greenhouse gases would harm the environment, hinder the advance of science and technology, and damage the health and welfare of mankind."
 
vetteman said:
I will say, I find it hard to believe that all 17,000 signers developed the bulk of their knowledge of global warming from the reading of this allegedly false document. In addition, the signed statement makes no reference to the document in question, instead it refers to,"substantial scientific evidence". Is it your contention that the document in question represents the bulk of their knowledge of that evidence?

This petition seems to have been sent not just to climatologists and other environmental scientists who'd be familiar with the latest literature but to physicists, geologists, chemists, biologists, as well (who likely wouldn't).

Even if they were acquainted with the latest literature of the day, and even if you didn't find fault with the methodology of the petition, it's still seven years old. Why should we accept it as a valid measurement of current scientific opinion?
 
Last edited:
I just did a skim back through this thread, and every single piece quoted by the deniers has a link to Exxon Mobil. Every. Single. One.
Astonishing.
 
vetteman said:
This from Charlton Heston, as excerpted from Michael Crichton's Jurassic Park:

HESTON: You think man can destroy the planet? What intoxicating vanity! Let me tell you about our planet. Earth is four-and-a-half-billion-years-old. There's been life on it for nearly that long, 3.8 billion years. Bacteria first; later the first multicellular life, then the first complex creatures in the sea, on the land. Then finally the great sweeping ages of animals, the amphibians, the dinosaurs, at last the mammals, each one enduring millions on millions of years, great dynasties of creatures rising, flourishing, dying away -- all this against a background of continuous and violent upheaval. Mountain ranges thrust up, eroded away, cometary impacts, volcano eruptions, oceans rising and falling, whole continents moving, an endless, constant, violent change, colliding, buckling to make mountains over millions of years. Earth has survived everything in its time.


It will certainly survive us. If all the nuclear weapons in the world went off at once and all the plants, all the animals died and the earth was sizzling hot for a hundred thousand years, life would survive, somewhere: under the soil, frozen in arctic ice. Sooner or later, when the planet was no longer inhospitable, life would spread again. The evolutionary process would begin again. Might take a few billion years for life to regain its present variety. Of course, it would be very different from what it is now, but the earth would survive our folly, only we would not. If the ozone layer gets thinner, ultraviolet radiation sears earth, so what? Ultraviolet radiation is good for life. It's powerful energy. It promotes mutation, change. Many forms of life will thrive with more UV radiation. Many others will die out. You think this is the first time that's happened? Think about oxygen. Necessary for life now, but oxygen is actually a metabolic poison, a corrosive glass, like fluorine.

When oxygen was first produced as a waste product by certain plant cells some three billion years ago, it created a crisis for all other life on earth. Those plants were polluting the environment, exhaling a lethal gas. Earth eventually had an atmosphere incompatible with life. Nevertheless, life on earth took care of itself. In the thinking of the human being a hundred years is a long time. Hundred years ago we didn't have cars, airplanes, computers or vaccines. It was a whole different world, but to the earth, a hundred years is nothing. A million years is nothing. This planet lives and breathes on a much vaster scale. We can't imagine its slow and powerful rhythms, and we haven't got the humility to try. We've been residents here for the blink of an eye. If we're gone tomorrow, the earth will not miss us.

It's not about whether or not "man can destroy the planet", it's about whether or not we hurry along our own demise. The sun will give out some day, but hopefully not tomorrow as I'm getting my hair done. Your quote is a powerful and timely reminder of our fragility. It would make a nice suicide note for the human race methinks.
 
vetteman said:
The question isn't whether we should except it or not, but what they accepted and agreed to. To believe that climatologists are the only people on earth who may render a valid opinion on the subject precludes the validity of our conversation here. It wasn't my contention that it represented the latest understanding of the problem, only that highly educated people at one time registered a different opinion. Sean pointed out that the study was false. I wanted to know the basic assumption they thought they were agreeing to.

We're not just having a discussion on the methods of surveys and petitions here. We're discussing the topic of global warming and the role of science in informing and motivating political action. This survey was advanced as evidence that there's not sufficient consensus to accept the premise behind legislation aiming to reduce or reverse global climate change.

What's important to our discussion is current scientific consensus on this matter. Otherwise we're debating historical matters. If Ham Murabi is going to use it as evidence for why we shouldn't advocate for addressing this issue politically then its currency is very much an issue.
 
It's a safe bet that most people posting here have read at least a little bit about global warming.
I invite those who are paying attention to pay a little bit more attention. Read an AP story that refers to global warming and see for yourself if the reporter cites any evidence or just takes it at face value that the climate is changing.
One I remember specifically related to Native Americans ruing the loss of game for hunting due to global warming. No evidence was cited to prove that area was actually warmer or that the climate was different, nor was any evidence provided that there were fewer elk, deer, antelope, rabbits, whatever.
I've lived in the desert for years. It doesn't rain much here - one year it had to rain like a bastard between Christmas and New Year's Eve just to get the annual total to just a hair over 2 inches.
Lately I've been reading this persistent dry state is attributed to climate change. Go figure.
BTW, since SeanH is so quick to label anyone who disagrees with him as a liar and a Nazi, I can only conclude that SeanH is a liar and a Nazi.
And a big government stooge who doesn't trust himself with a gun.
 
Ham Murabi said:
BTW, since SeanH is so quick to label anyone who disagrees with him as a liar and a Nazi, I can only conclude that SeanH is a liar and a Nazi.
And a big government stooge who doesn't trust himself with a gun.
You keep posting lies, I'll keep calling you a liar. Simple.
As for Nazi, the only two people that I've used that particular epithet to are Ishtard and Retrieval, both of whom have provided ample evidence to justify its use.
 
SeanH said:
You keep posting lies, I'll keep calling you a liar. Simple.
As for Nazi, the only two people that I've used that particular epithet to are Ishtard and Retrieval, both of whom have provided ample evidence to justify its use.

LIAR! NAZI!
No, wait. That's getting stale.
NAZI! LIAR!
 
Toldya....Gore is making big dough off you LOSERS

UK News
'Global Warming Is Lies' Claims Documentary
Sunday, 4th March 2007, 11:04

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Accepted theories about man causing global warming are "lies" claims a controversial new TV documentary.

‘The Great Global Warming Swindle’ - backed by eminent scientists - is set to rock the accepted consensus that climate change is being driven by humans.

The programme, to be screened on Channel 4 on Thursday March 8, will see a series of respected scientists attack the "propaganda" that they claim is killing the world’s poor.

Even the co-founder of Greenpeace, Patrick Moore, is shown, claiming African countries should be encouraged to burn more CO2.

Nobody in the documentary defends the greenhouse effect theory, as it claims that climate change is natural, has been occurring for years, and ice falling from glaciers is just the spring break-up and as normal as leaves falling in autumn.

A source at Channel 4 said: "It is essentially a polemic and we are expecting it to cause trouble, but this is the controversial programming that Channel 4 is renowned for."

Controversial director Martin Durkin said: "You can see the problems with the science of global warming, but people just don’t believe you – it’s taken ten years to get this commissioned.

"I think it will go down in history as the first chapter in a new era of the relationship between scientists and society. Legitimate scientists – people with qualifications – are the bad guys.

"It is a big story that is going to cause controversy.

"It’s very rare that a film changes history, but I think this is a turning point and in five years the idea that the greenhouse effect is the main reason behind global warming will be seen as total bollocks.

"Al Gore might have won an Oscar for ‘An Inconvenient Truth’, but the film is very misleading and he has got the relationship between CO2 and climate change the wrong way round."

One major piece of evidence of CO2 causing global warming are ice core samples from Antarctica, which show that for hundreds of years, global warming has been accompanied by higher levels of CO2 in the atmosphere.

In ‘The Great Global Warming Swindle’ Al Gore is shown claiming this proves the theory, but palaeontologist Professor Ian Clark claims in the documentary that it actually shows the opposite.

He has evidence showing that warmer spells in the Earth’s history actually came an average of 800 years before the rise in CO2 levels.

Prof Clark believes increased levels of CO2 are because the Earth is heating up and not the cause. He says most CO2 in the atmosphere comes from the oceans, which dissolve the gas.

When the temperature increases, more gas is released into the atmosphere and when global temperatures cool, more CO2 is taken in. Because of the immense size of the oceans, he said they take time to catch up with climate trends, and this ‘memory effect’ is responsible for the lag.

Scientists in the programme also raise another discrepancy with the official line, showing that most of the recent global warming occurred before 1940, when global temperatures then fell for four decades.

It was only in the late 1970s that the current trend of rising temperatures began.

This, claim the sceptics, is a flaw in the CO2 theory, because the post-war economic boom produced more CO2 and should, according to the consensus, have meant a rise in global temperatures.

The programme claims there appears to be a consensus across science that CO2 is responsible for global warming, but Professor Paul Reiter is shown to disagree.

He said the influential United Nations report on Climate change, that claimed humans were responsible, was a sham.

It claimed to be the opinion of 2,500 leading scientists, but Prof Reiter said it included names of scientists who disagreed with the findings and resigned from the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, and said the report was finalised by government appointees.

The CO2 theory is further undermined by claims that billions of pounds is being provided by governments to fund greenhouse effect research, so thousands of scientists know their job depends on the theory continuing to be seen as fact.

The programme claims efforts to reduce CO2 are killing Africans, who have to burn fires inside their home, causing cancer and lung damage, because their governments are being encouraged to use wind and solar panels that are not capable of supplying the continent with electricity, instead of coal and oil-burning power stations that could.

Greenpeace co-founder Patrick Moore is shown saying: "Environmentalists have romanticised peasant life, but this is anti-human.

"They are saying the world’s poorest people should have the world’s most expensive form of form of energy – really saying they can’t have electricity."

Gary Calder, a former editor of New Scientist, is featured in the programme, and has just released a book claiming that clouds are the real reason behind climate change.

‘The Chilling Stars’ was written with Danish scientist Henrik Svensmark who published a scientific paper, claiming cosmic rays cause clouds to form, reducing the global temperature. The theory is shown in the programme.

Mr Calder said: "Henrik Svensmark saw that cloudiness varies according to how many atomic particles are coming in from exploded stars - when there are more cosmic rays, there are more clouds.

"However, solar winds bat away many of the cosmic rays and the sun is currently in its most active phase, which would be an explanation for global warming.

"I am a science journalist and in my career I have been told by eminent scientists that black holes do not exist and it is impossible that continents move, but in science the experts are usually wrong.

"For me this is a cracking science story – I don’t come from any political position and I’m certainly not funded by the multinationals, although my bank manager would like me to be.

"I talk to scientists and come up with one story, and Al Gore talks to another set of scientists and comes up with a different story.

"So knowing which scientists to talk to is part of the skill. Some, who appear to be disinterested, are themselves getting billions of dollars of research money from the government.

"The few millions of dollars of research money from multinationals can’t compare to government funding, so you find the American scientific establishment is all for man-made global warming.

"We have the same situation in Britain The government’s chief scientific advisor Sir David King is supposed to be the representative of all that is good in British science, so it is disturbing he and the government are ignoring a raft of evidence against the greenhouse effect being the main driver against climate change."

The programme shows how the global warming research drive began when Margaret Thatcher gave money to scientists to ‘prove’ burning coal and oil was harmful, as part of her drive for nuclear power.

Philip Stott, professor emeritus of biogeography at the School of Oriental and African Studies in London , who also features in the film warned the issue was too complex to be down to one single factor, whether CO2 or clouds.

He said: "The greenhouse effect theory worried me from the start because you can’t say that just one factor can have this effect.

"The system is too complex to say exactly what the effect of cutting back on CO2 production would be, or indeed of continuing to produce CO2.

"It’s ridiculous to see politicians arguing over whether they will allow the global temperature to rise by 2C or 3C."

Mr Stott said the film could mark the point where scientists advocating the greenhouse effect theory, began to lose the argument.

He continued: "It is a brave programme at the moment to give excluded voices their say, and maybe it is just the beginning.

"At the moment, there is almost a McCarthyism movement in science where the greenhouse effect is like a puritanical religion and this is dangerous."

In the programme Nigel Calder says: "The greenhouse effect is seen as a religion and if you don’t agree, you are a heretic.

He added: "However, I think this programme will help further debate and scientists not directly involved in global warming studies may begin to study what is being said, become more open-minded and more questioning, but this will happen slowly."
 
ROTFL. This has been in the press for months, boys. And look who uses the Nazi epithet:
In 1997 television producer Martin Durkin from the TV company Kugelblitz made a series for Channel 4 called Against Nature, which targeted environmentalists, presenting them as 'the new enemy of science' and as comparable to the Nazis. They were responsible, the series argued, for the deprivation and death of millions in the Third World. (Crimes against Nature , The Revolution Has Been Televised )

Channel Four had to broadcast a prime-time apology after Against Nature drew the wrath of the Independent Television Commission which ruled, 'Comparison of the unedited and edited transcripts confirmed that the editing of the interviews with [the environmentalists who contributed] had indeed distorted or misrepresented their known views. It was also found that the production company had misled them... as to the format, subject matter and purpose of these programs.' (See CHANNEL 4 SAVAGED BY TELEVISION WATCHDOG )

Having seen the programes in advance, the Guardian's Environment correspondent, John Vidal, sought to identify the perspective from which the programmes had been made, 'I only know of one broad group which consistently uses this sort of argument about "environmentalism''. The Far Right. In the US, the Wise Use Movement is linked to the militias and its members beat up environmentalists who they call ''commies''. In South America and Asia, corporations and landowners spend millions killing them and bribing or influencing politicians against their arguments. Against Nature appears to peddle their line, yet C4 either can't see it or approves.'

Vidal's conclusion was understandable as the series provided a platform for a whole string of contributors from the Far Right but those behind Against Nature were not the usual right wing suspects. Rather, as Guardian columnist George Monbiot noted, the critical links were to a network then centered on the magazine LM, formerly known as Living Marxism , the monthly review of the Revolutionary Communist Party (RCP).

Monbiot writes, 'The assistant producer of Against Nature, Eve Kaye, was one of the principal coordinators of the RCP/LM. The director, Martin Durkin, describes himself as a Marxist, denies any link with LM, but precisely follows its line in argument. The series starred Frank Furedi, previously known as Frank Richards, LM's regular columnist and most influential thinker, and John Gillott, LM's science correspondent, both billed as independent experts. Line by line, point by point, Against Nature followed the agenda laid down by LM: that greens are not radicals, but doom-mongering imperialists; that global warming is nothing to worry about; that "sustainable development" is a conspiracy against people; while germline gene therapy and human cloning will liberate humanity from nature.'

Durkin's hidden agenda and controversial methods did not stop Channel 4 from making further use of his services, as Private Eye noted in February 2000, 'What does Channel 4 do with programme makers condemned by the TV watchdog, the Independent Television Commission (ITC), for using underhand editing techniques? The answer is, er, hire them to make another programme... Despite the damning ITC judgement the programme was seen at Channel 4 as somthing of a triumph, and science programmes commissioning editor Sarah Ramsden recieved high praise. Now Durkin is back with TV company Kugelblitz to make another programme in defence of genetic modification for Channel 4's 'Equinox' series.'

'Modified Truth: The Rise and Fall of GM' was broadcast on March 20 2000. It presented GM food as perfectly safe and as much needed to feed the starving in the Third World. Dr. Tewolde Gebre Egziaber of Ethiopia was among multiple signatories from the Third World who complained in a joint letter following the programme that it was a propaganda vehicle that made use of the Third World's rural poverty to support the monopoly control and global use of genetically modified food production by transnational corporations and emotionally blackmail the UK public into using GM (Joint Letter).

Two scientists critical of genetic engineering who were invited to contribute to the programme, Dr Arpad Pusztai and Dr Mae-Wan Ho, both subsequently complained that they were misled about the content and were not given a chance to reply to attacks on their positions (Pusztai's comments). Dr Ho said , 'I feel completely betrayed and misled. They did not tell me it was going to be an attack on my position.'

They are far from the only ones to complain about Durkin's methods. Contributors to a Durkin-directed Equinox programme about breast implants, which argued implants reduce the incidence of breast cancer, complained of the programme makers' deceptive tactics: 'In discussions with Martin Durkin's "Kugelblitz" crew as to the content of their proposed "science documentary" on silicone breast implants last year, we were totally and unequivocally misled as to the intent and content of that piece.' Durkin's proposal for the programme had earlier been rejected by the BBC because it 'ignored a powerful body of evidence contradicting his [Durkin's] claims'. A researcher hired to help Durkin make the Equinox programme resigned because, 'my research was being ignored. The published research had been construed to give an impression that's not the case. I don't know how that programme got passed.'

Articles on Martin Durkin and his programmes by George Monbiot:

Getting your science from charlatans:This man takes liberties with facts

The Revolution Has Been Televised: Channel 4's Against Nature series turns out to have been made by an obscure and cranky sect.

Crimes Against Nature : A new Channel 4 series would be laughable, had it not been given three hours of prime time TV
 
vetteman said:
From the article:

The film features an impressive roll-call of experts, including nine professors – experts in climatology, oceanography, meteorology, environmental science, biogeography and paleoclimatology – from such reputable institutions as MIT, NASA, the International Arctic Research Centre, the Institut Pasteur, the Danish National Space Center and the Universities of London, Ottawa, Jerusalem, Winnipeg, Alabama and Virginia.
.


LIARS

NAZI's

JEWS

and even

GASP

The DEVILS THEMSELVES, Israeli's............

Who pays em, Exxxon, Phil Morris, Pat Robertson?

Shoot em, hang em

make em have sex with Ann C! :cool:
 
vetteman said:
I wasn't dodging anything.

It is kind of Nazi like to ID kids, kind of like giving them a SS number eighteen years before they will enter the labor market. The only difference is it isn't being tattooed on them yet.

Aren't they doing that in schools here?

In case the kid gets kidnapped?
 
MinkSoul said:
Aren't they doing that in schools here?

In case the kid gets kidnapped?

Exactly! Obviously the old timers think this is nazi-esque. I see it as a way to keep my children safe from being grabbed. But I'll bet those that are claim8ing this as bad will spew their shit that it's all in a "secret" database. Isn't police record secret? FBI records? For that matter don't they keep fingerprint records on passports and I also believe the military keeps a finger print record of all prior and current members?

Damn, I guess the entire world has gotten "Nazi-Esque".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top