Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Bs Is Falling Apart!

Allegre's second thoughts

The Deniers -- The National Post's series on scientists who buck the conventional wisdom on climate science

LAWRENCE SOLOMON, Financial Post

Published: Friday, March 02, 2007
Claude Allegre, one of France's leading socialists and among her most celebrated scientists, was among the first to sound the alarm about the dangers of global warming.

"By burning fossil fuels, man increased the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere which, for example, has raised the global mean temperature by half a degree in the last century," Dr. Allegre, a renowned geochemist, wrote 20 years ago in Cles pour la geologie.." Fifteen years ago, Dr. Allegre was among the 1500 prominent scientists who signed "World Scientists' Warning to Humanity," a highly publicized letter stressing that global warming's "potential risks are very great" and demanding a new caring ethic that recognizes the globe's fragility in order to stave off "spirals of environmental decline, poverty, and unrest, leading to social, economic and environmental collapse."

Climate change: The Deniers
The Post's series on scientists who buck the conventional wisdom on climate science. Here is the series so far:





In the 1980s and early 1990s, when concern about global warming was in its infancy, little was known about the mechanics of how it could occur, or the consequences that could befall us. Since then, governments throughout the western world and bodies such as the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change have commissioned billions of dollars worth of research by thousands of scientists. With a wealth of data now in, Dr. Allegre has recanted his views. To his surprise, the many climate models and studies failed dismally in establishing a man-made cause of catastrophic global warming. Meanwhile, increasing evidence indicates that most of the warming comes of natural phenomena. Dr. Allegre now sees global warming as over-hyped and an environmental concern of second rank.

His break with what he now sees as environmental cant on climate change came in September, in an article entitled "The Snows of Kilimanjaro" in l' Express, the French weekly. His article cited evidence that Antarctica is gaining ice and that Kilimanjaro's retreating snow caps, among other global-warming concerns, come from natural causes. "The cause of this climate change is unknown," he states matter of factly. There is no basis for saying, as most do, that the "science is settled."

Dr. Allegre's skepticism is noteworthy in several respects. For one, he is an exalted member of France's political establishment, a friend of former Socialist president Lionel Jospin, and, from 1997 to 2000, his minister of education, research and technology, charged with improving the quality of government research through closer co-operation with France's educational institutions. For another, Dr. Allegre has the highest environmental credentials. The author of early environmental books, he fought successful battles to protect the ozone layer from CFCs and public health from lead pollution. His break with scientific dogma over global warming came at a personal cost: Colleagues in both the governmental and environmental spheres were aghast that he could publicly question the science behind climate change.

But Dr. Allegre had allegiances to more than his socialist and environmental colleagues. He is, above all, a scientist of the first order, the architect of isotope geodynamics, which showed that the atmosphere was primarily formed early in the history of the Earth, and the geochemical modeller of the early solar system. Because of his path-breaking cosmochemical research, NASA asked Dr. Allegre to participate in the Apollo lunar program, where he helped determine the age of the Moon. Matching his scientific accomplishments in the cosmos are his accomplishments at home: Dr. Allegre is perhaps best known for his research on the structural and geochemical evolution of the Earth's crust and the creation of its mountains, explaining both the title of his article in l' Express and his revulsion at the nihilistic nature of the climate research debate.


Calling the arguments of those who see catastrophe in climate change "simplistic and obscuring the true dangers," Dr. Allegre especially despairs at "the greenhouse-gas fanatics whose proclamations consist in denouncing man's role on the climate without doing anything about it except organizing conferences and preparing protocols that become dead letters." The world would be better off, Dr. Allegre believes, if these "denouncers" became less political and more practical, by proposing practical solutions to head off the dangers they see, such as developing technologies to sequester C02. His dream, he says, is to see "ecology become the engine of economic development and not an artificial obstacle that creates fear."

Lawrence Solomon@nextcity.com

- - -

- Lawrence Solomon is executive director of Urban Renaissance Institute and Consumer Policy Institute, divisions of Energy Probe Research Foundation.

CV OF A DENIER:

Claude Allegre received a Ph D in physics in 1962 from the University of Paris. He became the director of the geochemistry and cosmochemistry program at the French National Scientific Research Centre in 1967 and in 1971, he was appointed director of the University of Paris's Department of Earth Sciences. In 1976, he became director of the Paris Institut de Physique du Globe. He is an author of more than 100 scientific articles, many of them seminal studies on the evolution of the Earth using isotopic evidence, and 11 books. He is a member of the U.S. National Academy of Sciences and the French Academy of Science.
 
busybody said:
Calling the arguments of those who see catastrophe in climate change "simplistic and obscuring the true dangers," Dr. Allegre especially despairs at "the greenhouse-gas fanatics whose proclamations consist in denouncing man's role on the climate without doing anything about it except organizing conferences and preparing protocols that become dead letters." The world would be better off, Dr. Allegre believes, if these "denouncers" became less political and more practical, by proposing practical solutions to head off the dangers they see, such as developing technologies to sequester C02. His dream, he says, is to see "ecology become the engine of economic development and not an artificial obstacle that creates fear."

This is similar to what I have been saying as well. Should we do more? Yes. Should be strive to do better? Absolutely. Is the answer mass hysteria and impractical, extreme 'solutions'? No. Think globally and act locally is a great slogan. A powerful message that encourages all to lead by example as opposed to the 'do as I demand, not as I do' crowd. Too bad so many interpret this to mean 'think - the sky is falling (tomorrow) - and demand that everyone else ride bikes to work and live in darkness when the sun goes down...
 
vetteman said:
Careful now that kind of common sense will get you a Rightwing Fanatic label from the Tub Thumpers For Turmoil crowd. ;)

It's worse than that. I was recently labeled a 'Refreshing VOR' (voice of reason). I'm sill trying to figure out if that was intended to be an insult... :D
 
dcraz said:
It's worse than that. I was recently labeled a 'Refreshing VOR' (voice of reason). I'm sill trying to figure out if that was intended to be an insult... :D
Yes

If you dont believe Algore aka THE GORACLE is a SAINT and GW will kill children women and minorities

If you dont believe Bush is Hitler and kills American boys and girls for the sale of oil

If you ever ever dared to utter the word Republican

If you dont want to pay reperations and higher taxes

If you want the min wage to be $150,000 per 6 months

If you dont believe the Dimz are our saviours

If you believe the TERRORISTS are only doing what they are because Bush forced them to

You are a VOR and therefore EVIL!
 
busybody said:
Yes

If you dont believe Algore aka THE GORACLE is a SAINT and GW will kill children women and minorities

If you dont believe Bush is Hitler and kills American boys and girls for the sale of oil

If you ever ever dared to utter the word Republican

If you dont want to pay reperations and higher taxes

If you want the min wage to be $150,000 per 6 months

If you dont believe the Dimz are our saviours

If you believe the TERRORISTS are only doing what they are because Bush forced them to

You are a VOR and therefore EVIL!


Well let's see...

I happen to think Al Gore is a funny, very likable guy. When he is not running for office or pontificating on some subject. For instance, his concession speech and appearances immediately after the election showed a very engaging and welcoming persona. If THAT person had run for president, he would have won in a land side. And I don't know about children, but Bush is from Texas where we have the death penalty. And we have certainly led the charge in killing minorities, women and other 'oppressed' groups of convicted, cold blooded killers. Jury still out on where I stand on that one. So to speak (no pun intended).

I would not suggest that Bush kills American boys an girls for oil. But he has led an army that lost men and women in the name of liberating a previously free and invaded country (Kuwait) and in dismantling an army and country that has publicly acknowledged engaging in genocide and a clear intent to attack the US when and where possible and to support others to do the same. Probably cannot check that box as I see it differently.

I have uttered the word republican and even used the word 'conservative' to describe my views. Check that box.

I'm afraid I already pay reparations (of a sort) in the form of reverse discrimination policies based on a perceived need to be overly fair to minorities because of past transgressions by whites and white owned businesses. And the fact that I pay in more taxes than the average democrat voter grosses in annual income speaks for itself. Check that box.

The minimum wage thing always got me. It is a MINIMUM wage and was NEVER intended to be a 'living wage' capable of supporting a family of four. It is an entry level wage to allow people to make something while they increase their value to their employer with increased skills and experience so as to be more valuable to said employer and EARN a higher wage. Can't check that box. As I explained to my own son several years ago when he was a bus boy complaining about how much he did not make and how he was treated like shit. I told him 'son, you are treated like shit because you ARE shit and you do a shit job'. Contrary to all those that think we should not keep score in little league for fear of hurting little Johnny's self esteem, life is a competition with winners and losers. Want to make more than minimum wage? Be worth more than minimum wage. Want to earn a living wage? Work like your life depends on it and quit whining about all the things you are not getting. Sorry, cannot check that box.

Of course the democrats are our savior. Or at least could be if I supported them. They make me feel good, tell me nothing is my fault, everything is because rich whitey is keeping me down and if I just vote for them, they will make sure the government takes care of me and protects me from all those mean spirited business men. They will make sure everyone gets a living wage, has all the benefits we can ask for. Regardless of whether industry or even the government can pay for it. OK. Maybe I SHOULD check that box. Now that I said it out loud, I am beginning to see the error of my ways... :rolleyes:

And it is clear that we should listen to and embrace the poor misunderstood terrorists and try to understand why are they so upset at us. And once we do, we should mend our evil ways so they will love us like the government should. I mean if someone broke into your house, shot you wife and raped your daughter, you would be sure to try to understand them and why they acted as they did right? I mean you obviously have done something to upset them so. You certainly would not advocate harming them in retaliation. Or heaven forbid, harming them before they had the chance to shoot your wife and rape your daughter... Not sure about that box. Need to think on it some more I suppose....
 
WE'RE JUST MORE HONEST: :D :D


UK plans to cut CO2 doomed to fail - scientists (James Randerson, March 5, 2007, The Guardian)


An independent scientific audit of the UK's climate change policies predicts that the government will fall well below its target of a 30% reduction in carbon dioxide emissions by 2020 - which means that the country will not reach its 2020 milestone until 2050.

The report condemns government forecasts on greenhouse gas emissions as "very optimistic" and projects that the true reduction will be between 12 and 17%, making little difference to current CO2 emission levels.


At least we refused to adopt the Treaty before ignoring it. :catroar: :catroar: :catroar:
 
vetteman said:
Careful now that kind of common sense will get you a Rightwing Fanatic label from the Tub Thumpers For Turmoil crowd. ;)


Nah, the only thing that gets you labelled as a Right-wing brainless fanantic is insisting that man has played no part in accellerating global warming, or worse yet, denying that it exists at all.
 
they MAKE SHIT UP!

Yup, THE UN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change is not only a treaty, but an organization, a subordinate office of the UN with fancy offices in Bonn from which it plans fancy meetings in pursuit of the mission of both the group and the treaty: promoting treaties reducing anthropogenic emissions from the most abundant, affordable and reliable sources of energy known to Man, hydrocarbons ("fossil fuels"), known as "greenhouse gases".

The UNFCCC has a website, on which it promotes (select) news items advancing its cause, curiously sidestepping others.

Today's post is amusing, illuminating the cynic as to whom the UNFCCC sees as its actual boss(es):

“Latest Headlines: ‘Pressured by environmentalists, UN chief decries global warming,’ AFP" :eek: :eek: :eek: :eek:
 
Gee, I wonder when the Gorbasm will go to China and scream at the chinks?


A WARMING WORLD
China about to pass U.S. as world's top generator of greenhouse gases
Robert Collier, Chronicle Staff Writer

Monday, March 5, 2007





Far more than previously acknowledged, the battle against global warming will be won or lost in China, even more so than in the West, new data show.

A report released last week by Beijing authorities indicated that as its economy continues to expand at a red-hot pace, China is highly likely to overtake the United States this year or in 2008 as the world's largest emitter of greenhouse gases.

This information, along with data from the International Energy Agency, the Paris-based alliance of oil importing nations, also revealed that China's greenhouse gas emissions have recently been growing by a total amount much greater than that of all industrialized nations put together.

"The magnitude of what's happening in China threatens to wipe out what's happening internationally," said David Fridley, leader of the China Energy Group at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory.

"Today's global warming problem has been caused mainly by us in the West, with the cumulative (carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases) in the atmosphere, but China is contributing to the global warming problem of tomorrow."

New statistics released in Beijing on Wednesday by China's National Bureau of Statistics show that China's consumption of fossil fuels rose in 2006 by 9.3 percent, about the same rate as in previous years -- and about eight times higher than the U.S. increase of 1.2 percent.

While China's total greenhouse gas emissions were only 42 percent of the U.S. level in 2001, they had soared to an estimated 97 percent of the American level by 2006.

"The new data are not encouraging," said Yang Fuqiang, China director for the Energy Foundation, a San Francisco organization that works extensively with Lawrence Berkeley scientists and the Chinese government on energy-saving programs. "China will overtake the United States much faster than expected as the No. 1 emitter."

China's top environmental official admitted Wednesday that the results show the government's environment agenda of the past few years has been ineffective.

"Economic growth is still excessive ... and there is slow progress in restructuring obsolete and backward production capacity," said Zhou Shengxian, director of the State Environmental Protection Agency.

"The new data show that many local officials are more concerned about economic development, about increasing gross domestic product, and see energy efficiency and environmental protection as a lower priority," said Yang, of the Energy Foundation.

In an attempt to force local governments to obey energy-efficiency edicts from Beijing, the government recently announced that local officials' pay and promotion will be judged in part based on their environmental record, not just their economic success. The first evaluation period will be in July.

China's emergence as a global warming polluter has been intensely controversial in international negotiations over climate change.

The Bush administration refused to join the Kyoto Protocol in part because the pact committed only industrialized nations, but not fast-growing poorer nations like China, to reduce their emissions of greenhouse gases.

Chinese officials, however, note that the country's per capita emissions are far below those in the West, and they say any move to adopt mandatory cuts now would restrain its economic growth and in effect penalize its 1.3 billion people for being poor. The officials say China must be given the chance to attain the West's standard of prosperity before it will cut emissions.

"It must be pointed out that climate change has been caused by the long-term historic emissions of developed countries and their high per-capita emissions," China's Foreign Ministry spokeswoman, Jiang Yu, said last month.

"Developed countries bear an unshirkable responsibility," she said, adding that they should "lead the way in assuming responsibility for emissions cuts."

International negotiations have begun over a successor pact to the Kyoto Protocol, and industrial nations -- and most environmentalists -- are insisting that big developing nations such as China, India and Brazil commit to reductions.

China's hard line may finally be softening, however.

The Chinese government recently admitted that global warming will dramatically impact China's ability to feed its people. A government report released in January said that climate change will cause China's production of wheat, corn and rice to drop by as much as 37 percent over the next 50 years.

Precipitation over the country's northern grainbelt is expected to drop markedly, causing worsened droughts and dust storms, while increased flooding and typhoons are expected in the subtropical south, the report said.

What China needs, many experts say, is help from the United States and other Western nations to help adopt energy-saving technologies. China's energy consumption per unit of production is 40 percent higher than the world's average, and about 70 percent of its energy comes from coal, usually burned in highly inefficient power plants.

The U.S. Energy Department carries out some technical cooperation with China on issues such as coal, but most forms of U.S. assistance to China have been barred under sanctions imposed by Congress after the 1989 Tiananmen killings in Beijing.

Although Chinese officials say their country should receive foreign grants and subsidies, the Central Bank has the world's highest foreign-exchange reserves, at $1.1 trillion, so most experts say China needs training and technology rather than cash.

China has much to learn from California, said Barbara Finamore, director of the China program of the Natural Resources Defense Council.

The state's Energy Commission and Public Utilities Commission have exchanged information with their counterparts in China in recent years, but Finamore said much more is needed to help spread California's energy-efficient ways.

"This is what China is missing," Finamore said, referring to the state's complex mix of efficiency standards for buildings, appliances and industry. "We have no national energy-efficiency program, but 20 U.S. states use them, and China is on the brink of using them."
 
But you don't believe in greenhouse gasses, BB. Man has no effect on the climate, remember?
 
Funny stuff


How Gore's massive energy consumption saves the world

By Mark Steyn

Stop me if you've heard this before, but the other day the Rev. Al Gore declared that "climate change" was "the most important moral, ethical, spiritual and political issue humankind has ever faced.'' Ever. I believe that was the same day it was revealed that George W. Bush's ranch in Texas is more environmentally friendly than the Gore mansion in Tennessee. According to the Nashville Electric Service, the Eco-Messiah's house uses 20 times more electricity than the average American home. The average household consumes 10,656 kilowatt-hours. In 2006, the Gores wolfed down nearly 221,000 kilowatt-hours.


Two hundred twenty-one thousand kilowatt-hours? What's he doing in there? Clamping Tipper to the electrodes and zapping her across the rec room every night? No, no, don't worry. Al's massive energy consumption is due entirely to his concern about the way we're depleting the Earth's resources. When I say "we," I don't mean Al, of course. I mean you —yes, you, Earl Schlub, in the basement apartment at 29 Elm St. You're irresponsibly depleting the Earth's resources by using that electric washer when you could be down by the river with the native women beating your loin cloth dry on the rock while singing traditional village work chants all morning long. But up at the Gore mansion —the Nashville Electric Service's own personal gold mine, the shining Cathedral of St. Al, Tennessee's very own Palace of Versal —the Reverend Al is being far more environmentally responsible. As his spokesperson attempted to argue, his high energy usage derives from his brave calls for low energy usage. He's burning up all that electricity by sending out faxes every couple of minutes urging you to use less electricity.


Also he buys —and if you're a practicing Ecopalyptic please prostrate yourself before the Recycling Bin and make the sign of the HDPE —Al buys "carbon offsets," or "carbon credits." Or, as his spokesperson Kalee Kreider put it (and, incidentally, speaking through a spokesperson is another way Al dramatically reduces his own emissions), the Gores "also do the carbon emissions offset."


They do the Carbon Emissions Offset? What is that —a '60s dance craze? No, it's way hotter. I mean, cooler. All the movie stars are doing it. In fact, this year's Oscar goodie-bag that all the nominees get included a year's worth of carbon offsets. Totally free. So even the stars' offsets are offset. No wonder that, when they're off the set, they all do the offset. Look at Leonardo DiCaprio: He's loaded with 'em, and the chicks think he's totally eco-cool. Tall and tan and young and lovely, the boy with carbon offsets goes walking and when he passes each one he passes goes aaaiiieeeeeeeee!


How do "carbon offsets" work? Well, let's say you're a former vice president and you want to reduce your "carbon footprint," but the gorgeous go-go Gore gals are using the hair dryer every night. So you go to a carbon-credits firm and pay some money and they'll find a way of getting somebody on the other side of the planet to reduce his emissions and the net result will be "carbon neutral." It's like in Henry VIII's day. He'd be planning a big ox roast and piling on the calories but he'd give a groat to a starving peasant to carry on starving for another day and the result would be calorie-neutral.


So in the Reverend Al's case it doesn't matter that he's lit up like Times Square on V-E Day. Because he's paid for his extravagant emissions. He has a carbon-offset trader in an environmentally friendly carbon-credits office suite who buys "carbon offsets" for Al from, say, a terrorist mastermind in a cave in the Pakistani tribal lands who's dramatically reduced his energy usage mainly because every time he powers up his cell phone or laptop a light goes on in Washington and an unmanned drone starts heading his way. So, aside from a basic cable subscription to cheer himself up watching U.S. senators talking about "exit strategies" on CNN 24/7, the terrorist mastermind doesn't deplete a lot of resources. Which means Tipper can watch Al give a speech on a widescreen plasma TV, where Al looks almost as wide as in life, and she doesn't have to feel guilty because it all comes out . . . carbon-neutral!


And, in fact, in the Reverend Al's case it's even better than that. Al buys his carbon offsets from Generation Investment Management LLP, which is "an independent, private, owner-managed partnership established in 2004 and with offices in London and Washington, D.C.," that, for a fee, will invest your money in "high-quality companies at attractive prices that will deliver superior long-term investment returns." Generation is a tax-exempt U.S. 501(c)3. And who's the chairman and founding partner? Al Gore.


So Al can buy his carbon offsets from himself. Better yet, he can buy them with the money he gets from his long-time relationship with Occidental Petroleum. See how easy it is to be carbon-neutral? All you have do is own a gazillion stocks in Big Oil, start an eco-stockbroking firm to make eco-friendly investments, use a small portion of your oil company's profits to buy some tax-deductible carbon offsets from your own investment firm, and you too can save the planet while making money and leaving a carbon footprint roughly the size of Godzilla's at the start of the movie when they're all standing around in the little toe wondering what the strange depression in the landscape is.


A couple of days before the Oscars, the Reverend Al gave a sell-out performance at the University of Toronto. "From my perspective, it is a form of religion," said Bruce Crofts of the East Toronto Climate Action Group, who compared the former vice president to Jesus Christ, both men being (as the Globe And Mail put it) "great leaders who stepped forward when called upon by circumstance." Unlike Christ, the Eco-Messiah cannot yet walk on water, but then, neither can the polar bears. However, only Al can survey the melting ice caps and turn water into whine. One lady unable to land a ticket frantically begged the university for an audience with His Goriness. As the National Post reported, "Her daughter hadn't been able to sleep since seeing ''An Inconvenient Truth.'' She claimed that seeing Mr. Gore in person might make her daughter feel better." Well, it worked for Leonardo DiCaprio.


Are eco-celebrities buying ridiculousness-emissions credits from exhausted run-of-the-mill celebrities like Paris, Britney and Anna Nicole? Ah, well. The Eco-Messiah sternly talks up the old Nazi comparisons: What we're facing is an "ecological Holocaust, and "the evidence of an ecological Kristallnacht is as clear as the sound of glass shattering in Berlin." That 221,000 kilowatt-hours might suggest that, if this is the ecological Holocaust, Gore's pad is Auschwitz. But, as his spokesperson would no doubt argue, when you're faced with ecological Holocausts and ecological Kristallnachts, sometimes the only way to bring it to an end is with an ecological Hiroshima. The Gore electric bill is the eco-atom bomb: You have to light up the world in order to save it.
 
Pity the electric bill for the White House is classified information.
 
Ulaven_Demorte said:
Nah, the only thing that gets you labelled as a Right-wing brainless fanantic is insisting that man has played no part in accellerating global warming, or worse yet, denying that it exists at all.


Well certainly man has and continues to play a role in it. And I will even go so far as to accept that it (global warming) exists. The historical evidence would suggest as much. But there are MANY questions yet to be answered.

How do we explain that global warming (this time) began PRIOR to the industrial revolution? How do we explain the numerous transitions from global warming to ice age and back again over the years? Who or what was to blame for them?

We do not yet understand global weather and climates. Let us be VERY clear on this point. While we can try to determine the amount of emissions we as humans create, we do not fully understand nor can we come close to predicting the contributions from other sources. We can guess, but they are nothing more than WILD guesses at this point. Nor can we identify with certainty that the emissions we are creating are the primary reason for the warming to begin with. Are they contributing factors? Almost certainly. Do we know to what extent? Absolutely we do not.

We cannot say for certain that even if we significantly reduced emissions that it would have any effect at all. Probably, but we just do not know. But the models cannot show us that reducing emission will cause a reversal or even a slowing of the warming trend. There are so many other factors we cannot begin to make accurate predictions.

Again, I think we SHOULD do more. I think we should try to reduce emissions. I believe this NOT because I am fearful of the 'sky is falling' message no matter how loudly they scream. Rather I believe this because as a responsible steward of the environment, I am concerned and want to do my part to understand and protect where practical. I am all about conservation. But it should be intelligent conservation.

What is interesting is the parallel to acid rain. Acid rain, not to be confused with global warming, IS real and identifiable and traceable directly to humans and industrial emissions. The evidence was real and accurately predictable. Once the problem was identified, measure were put in place to encourage cleaner technologies and to intelligently address the problem. Over the last 30 years, significant advances have been made and the problems associated with acid rain have been reduced. Through awareness, education and cooperation between industry and consumers. Unfortunately the same conclusions cannot be drawn when looking at global warming and perhaps that is why the message has become so extreme and emotional and moved away from mere education and awareness. Too bad really...

There is something else happening that is much more serious in my opinion. Something for which you will hear no outcry. The focus on global warming is so extreme and emotional as to take attention away from general matters of conservation. The very think locally concepts that provide DIRECT, IMMEDIATE and PERSONAL or LOCAL positive impacts. I'm speaking of recycling, rain or grey water collection systems, water conservation and xeriscaping, reduced waste and use of consumables, the increased use and focus on renewables, etc. Just as cancer has now taken a back seat to aids in funding and research (never mind the number of people that die from each in proportion to funding spent), global warming, by the very nature of its extreme message and hysterics, takes energy, interest and focus away from many other important and laudible efforts to 'save the environment'.
 
Last edited:
phrodeau said:
Pity the electric bill for the White House is classified information.

I would agree if....

The White House and current administration were the ones pontificating to the rest of the world about how WE are not doing enough, how WE should all be sitting in the dark after the sun goes down and how WE should all ride our bikes to work.

Yet it would appear that the man that lives in the mansion he owns does not practice what he preaches for the masses....
 
dcraz said:
I would agree if....

The White House and current administration were the ones pontificating to the rest of the world about how WE are not doing enough, how WE should all be sitting in the dark after the sun goes down and how WE should all ride our bikes to work.

Yet it would appear that the man that lives in the mansion he owns does not practice what he preaches for the masses....
I would agree if...

You could show me where Al Gore has said any of those things.
 
crazybbwgirl:
" Shit - I can't even decide on paper or plastic?!?!"

If you're serious - paper. I typically take plastic, however, as I use them for garbage bags.
 
SeanH said:
I just did a skim back through this thread, and every single piece quoted by the deniers has a link to Exxon Mobil. Every. Single. One.
Astonishing.
Ham Murabi makes the Black Knight look like Conan.
 
busybody said:
How bout you,FREAK, and other LOSER LIBS giving Bush Kudos for living in a green type mansion in Crawford?


If he would be pulling a GORACLE youd have your assholes puckered up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Bush is a fuckwit richboy that has no inkling of environmentalism and spends his life trying to undermine environmental science.

It may well be that he is also a tight cunt and wants to save every nickel he can on monthly household expenditure but rational thought suggests he can in no way be held up as a more glowing example of a forward thinking environmentalist that Al Gore may be. For fucks sake, just compare the outpourings from both men on environmental issues and Bush is into negative retarded antisciene. Good God, he appointed a Mobil bureaucrat to edit Government science reports for him.... what more can you say!
 
phrodeau said:
Pity the electric bill for the White House is classified information.

Is it? What electric bill would you like to see? The living quarters, the offices, the areas open for public tours?
 
Fuck YOU FREAK DOPE and Algore!

Freak DOPE

You mention the WHITE HOUSE

As if the TWO are comporable

I wonder if the WH uses 20,000 more then the avg home

and I see you SEEMED TO HAVE PRETENDED THIS DOESNT EXIST!


Yikes! Gore is an energy glutton. Now compare this to President Bush's comparatively modest home in Crawford, Texas, which is a model of environmental friendliness:

The 4,000-square-foot house is a model of environmental rectitude

Geothermal heat pumps located in a central closet circulate water through pipes buried 300 feet deep in the ground where the temperature is a constant 67 degrees; the water heats the house in the winter and cools it in the summer. Systems such as the one in this "eco-friendly" dwelling use about 25% of the electricity that traditional heating and cooling systems utilize.

A 25,000-gallon underground cistern collects rainwater gathered from roof runs; wastewater from sinks, toilets and showers goes into underground purifying tanks and is also funneled into the cistern. The water from the cistern is used to irrigate the landscaping surrounding the four-bedroom home. Plants and flowers native to the high prairie area blend the structure into the surrounding ecosystem.

No, this is not the home of some eccentrically wealthy eco-freak trying to shame his fellow citizens into following the pristineness of his self-righteous example. And no, it is not the wilderness retreat of the Sierra Club or the Natural Resources Defense Council, a haven where tree-huggers plot political strategy.

This is President George W. Bush's "Texas White House" outside the small town of Crawford.


Keep in mind that this piece by Rob Sullivan was first published in the Chicago Tribune in 2001, so the fact that President Bush's home was ecology friendly was not unknown in the media. They just chose to ignore it while they heaped praise on Gore.

And take a look at this piece from TreeHugger:

Only your dispassionate Canadian correspondent could write this without colour or favour, but is it possible that George Bush is a secret Green? Evidently his Crawford Winter White House has 25,000 gallons of rainwater storage, gray water collection from sinks and showers for irrigation, passive solar, geothermal heating and cooling. "By marketplace standards, the house is startlingly small," says David Heymann, the architect of the 4,000-square-foot home. "Clients of similar ilk are building 16-to-20,000-square-foot houses." Furthermore for thermal mass the walls are clad in "discards of a local stone called Leuders limestone, which is quarried in the area. The 12-to-18-inch-thick stone has a mix of colors on the top and bottom, with a cream- colored center that most people want. "They cut the top and bottom of it off because nobody really wants it," Heymann says. "So we bought all this throwaway stone. It's fabulous. It's got great color and it is relatively inexpensive." Hmm, back to that vote about the Greenest President?
George Bush lives environmentalism whereas Al Gore only gives it lip service, yet he's is hailed as God's greatest gift to the environment. Meanwhile, he greedily consumes far more energy than the average American who, by the way, would be footing the bill for Kyoto if we hadn't pull out of it.

Every single one of those actors at the Oscars last night who was applauding Al Gore and nodding his or her head in agreement when Gore said global warming is a moral issue not a political one, needs to take lessons on how to be eco-friendly from President Bush. Next time liberals smugly announce that they drive Priuses, laugh in their faces.

Hypocrisy, thy name is Gore.

By the way, read all of Sullivan's piece on President Bush's Crawford ranch. In spite of the president's efforts to build a home that is as environmentally friendly as possible, he nonetheless, reaches to ridiculous lengths to find ways to slam the president as being inconsistent:

I suppose in George W.'s architectural world only the rich and powerful have views; vistas that the public owns as part of its shared heritage are up for lease and sale.

Heymann also termed the house "stunningly small." Really? Would it be stunningly small for a single mother in South Central Los Angeles? How stunningly small would it be for an immigrant Latino family in San Antonio Maybe in the rarified heights where second homes are the norm, 4,000 square feet is small and on a stunning scale as well, but in Main Street America that much elbow room is pretty big for the first and only home.

But then most of us can't reconcile what might at first glance appear to be inherently irreconcilable. Maybe some day, like our noble president, we will be able to make that kind of staggering mental feat. That is, if we ever stop misunderestimating ourselves.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top