Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mar. 04, 2007
Copyright © Las Vegas Review-Journal

VIN SUPRYNOWICZ: Global warming and self-righteous zealots


Quite a bit of e-mail on last week's brief debunking of the current "global warming" hysteria, being promoted by the same folks who 30 years ago were predicting -- on the cover of Newsweek, and elsewhere -- that the next Ice Age was right around the corner.

Since Ice Ages arrive with considerable regularity (speaking in geologic time frames), and the next one is in fact due, they probably should have stuck with "Plan A."


Will these self-righteous zealots now agree in advance, based on their own statistically absurd "man-made greenhouse gases make all the difference" argument, that if and when temperatures do start to dip, the only way to stave off the Big Chill is to burn all the coal we can?

Why do I suspect not?

Or -- if they hate coal and oil so much -- will these modern flagellants instead endorse building hundreds of clean new nuclear power plants?

Oh dear. That's another "No," isn't it?

Let's see: Windmills are out because they kill birds and interfere with TV reception. We could try a million little gerbil-powered treadmill generators, I suppose. But the greens' PETA division would immediately brand us animal slavers, before we even get to the problem of gerbil flatulence pollution.

Come on, admit it: These people think the electricity that runs their PCs and hybrid golfcarts is manufactured by elves in hollow trees, don't they?

"Clearly, we are not undergoing man-made global warming. We may not even be undergoing global warming at all," writes in correspondent Corbett C.

"But why are politicians so interested in embracing this theory? Is it because the French & Germans hate us so much that they are willing to further injure their own economies in order to hurt ours? I don't think so. I think global warming is about providing cover for politicians.

"Politicians know that the world economy is about to collapse," Mr. C. continues. "They've been piling up debt and devaluing currency for almost 100 years. They know it is about time to pay the piper. The question a politician has to be asking is how to escape the blame for the coming economic disaster.

"How better than to blame it on something that is not going to happen? 'Sure, your standard of living is in the toilet, but which would you rather have -- a poor economy or the earth devoid of life? And by the way, we politicians are heroes because our quick action has saved the planet.'

"That's why GWB has jumped on the global warming bandwagon. (That and the fact that he sees yet another way to plunder the American people to give handouts to big business in the form of ethanol subsidies.) And that is why we're going to keep hearing about global warming, even as the climate becomes cooler. ..."

Maybe. Though the desperate desire of a Grecian Formula political class that doesn't even recognize a supermarket price scanner to demonstrate they're hip to the latest jive of the young people may be a simpler explanation. Pay a little lip service, play to the crowd, hope by next year they're back to saving the whales. Tell us again which Dylan tunes were your favorites, President Carter?

"Sir: Some 30 years after the panic of globaloney cooling (see Newsweek articles in 1975) we now have the panic of globaloney warming caused by mankind," adds Marc J., who reports earning his Ph.D. from UCLA.

"Greenland was green from the 10th to the 14th century; sunken tropical forests in Siberia and Alaska are the source of those huge petroleum and natural gas fields. ...

"On an average day there is in the air about 10,000 parts per million (ppm) of water vapor, and about 200 ppm of carbon dioxide. The rise of 100 ppm in the latter, with its thermal absorption of about one quarter that of water vapor, will therefore influence any increase in warming by some one-quarter of one percent.

"In other words, the carbon dioxide projected increase due to human activities, if it occurs, will be negligible in any warming or cooling trends in the foreseeable future.

"There is a 'Global Warming Petition' (see Internet) to the government, signed by more than 19,000 independent scientists, that states 'There is no scientific evidence that human release ... of greenhouse gases is causing or will, in the foreseeable future, cause catastrophic heating of the Earth's atmosphere and disruption in the Earth's climate. ...'

"The government-paid scientists ... are in my experience 90 percent private enterprise rejects who enjoy the prospects of ruling over the free people while nationalizing our corporations, telling us how to live in bondage to their dictates. ... Watch how the Hollywood rich lefties will confer the Oscar on that panic-mongering political fraud Al Gore this coming Sunday."

Next time:

Let's give a little rope to a typically silly Green critic, and see what he does with it.


Vin Suprynowicz (vsuprynowicz@reviewjournal.com) is the Review-Journal's assistant editorial page editor.
 
Ham Murabi said:
Quite a bit of e-mail on last week's brief debunking of the current "global warming" hysteria, being promoted by the same folks who 30 years ago were predicting -- on the cover of Newsweek, and elsewhere -- that the next Ice Age was right around the corner.
Start straight in with the lies, huh?
Post a link to where one reputable scientist claimed we were in for another ice age.
You have done nothing but post lies in this thread.
 
SeanH said:
Start straight in with the lies, huh?
Post a link to where one reputable scientist claimed we were in for another ice age.
You have done nothing but post lies in this thread.

LIAR! NAZI!
 
Google "Global Warming Petition" and click to see who has signed and how many Ph.D.s are attached to their names. And every damn one of them thinks global warming is so much horseshit.
On the other hand, SeanH has 2459933 percent of the scientists in the world, plus the president of his local Rock, Paper, Scissors chapter, firmly in his corner.
 
Ham Murabi said:
Google "Global Warming Petition" and click to see who has signed and how many Ph.D.s are attached to their names. And every damn one of them thinks global warming is so much horseshit.
On the other hand, SeanH has 2459933 percent of the scientists in the world, plus the president of his local Rock, Paper, Scissors chapter, firmly in his corner.
ROTFL. Jesus you're stupid, you don't even read your own thread, do you?
Google Oregon Petition, you fucking moron.
 
Ham Murabi said:
Google "Global Warming Petition" and click to see who has signed and how many Ph.D.s are attached to their names. And every damn one of them thinks global warming is so much horseshit.
On the other hand, SeanH has 2459933 percent of the scientists in the world, plus the president of his local Rock, Paper, Scissors chapter, firmly in his corner.

What would it take to change your mind on this?

Absolute consensus from the scientific community?

Political support from conservative leaders?

Or maybe nothing at all?
 
SeanH said:
When you Google for the petition, put the word "hoax" in there with it.
Fucking idiot.
What's the matter, Ham, your Google broken? Here, I'll help you out, mine works just fine:
http://www.ecosyn.us/adti/Corrupt_Sallie_Baliunas.html

A few gems from that page:
None of the coauthors of "Environmental Effects of Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide" had any more standing than Robinson himself as a climate change researcher. They included Robinson's 22-year-old son, Zachary (home-schooled by his dad), along with astrophysicists Sallie Baliunas and Willie Soon. Both Baliunas and Soon worked with Frederick Seitz at the George C. Marshall Institute, a Washington, D.C., think tank where Seitz served as executive director. Funded by a number of right-wing foundations, including Scaife and Bradley, the George C. Marshall Institute does not conduct any original research. It is a conservative think tank that was initially founded during the years of the Reagan administration to advocate funding for Reagan's Strategic Defense Initiative--the "Star Wars" weapons program. ... Following the collapse of the Soviet Union, however, the Marshall Institute has adapted to the times by devoting much of its firepower to the war against environmentalism, and in particular against the "scaremongers" who raise warnings about global warming.
The research was underwritten by the American Petroleum Institute, the trade association of the world's largest oil companies. Two of the five authors are scientists who have been linked to the coal industry and have received support from the ExxonMobil Foundation. Two others, who are affiliated with the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, also have the title of "senior scientists" with a Washington-based organization supported by ExxonMobil Corp.

The organization, the George T. Marshall Institute, is headed by William O'Keefe, a former executive of the American Petroleum Institute. He also was at one time the president of the Global Climate Coalition, a now-defunct organization created by oil and coal interests to lobby against U.S. participation in climate treaties, such as the Kyoto Protocol. ..
You should read the whole thing, it's hilarious.
 
SeanH said:
What's the matter, Ham, your Google broken? Here, I'll help you out, mine works just fine:
http://www.ecosyn.us/adti/Corrupt_Sallie_Baliunas.html

A few gems from that page:


You should read the whole thing, it's hilarious.

In 2005, Scientific American did a follow-up report on a sample of just those who claimed to be climatologists from the petition and found:

Scientific American took a sample of 30 of the 1,400 signatories claiming to hold a Ph.D. in a climate-related science. Of the 26 we were able to identify in various databases, 11 said they still agreed with the petition —- one was an active climate researcher, two others had relevant expertise, and eight signed based on an informal evaluation. Six said they would not sign the petition today, three did not remember any such petition, one had died, and five did not answer repeated messages. Crudely extrapolating, the petition supporters include a core of about 200 climate researchers – a respectable number, though rather a small fraction of the climatological community.
 
vetteman said:
To participate in the debate you agree to be constrained by Sean's sources, Sean's parameters, agree to recognize Sean as the final arbiter of truth and correctness...oh it helps to mimic the demeanor of a good liberal as well, while accepting the notion that behind an insulting, foul mouthed, inebriated poster, resides a pious, saintly, science minded, do gooder. Then you're in. :D
He tried to use the exact same lies that you did yesterday. The fucking moron didn't even read his own thread. There is no excuse for stupidity of that order, even from a wingnut.
 
vetteman said:
Okay I read it. The link sounds to me like it's a site biased in favor of your side. Let's for the moment say it's a total fraud. My question to you would be: What do you think those people were agreeing with when they signed that document?
A lie. They thought they were reading a peer reviewed paper published by the NAS.
 
Oliver Clozoff said:
What would it take to change your mind on this?

Absolute consensus from the scientific community?

Political support from conservative leaders?

Or maybe nothing at all?

So the LIE of consensus is no longer an argument? Good, :) Because as you can see, there is no fucking consensus and there NEVER was.

Now we can dispense with that bullshit as an argument.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
So the LIE of consensus is no longer an argument? Good, :) Because as you can see, there is no fucking consensus and there NEVER was.

Now we can dispense with that bullshit as an argument.

Ishmael
97% of the world's climate scientists sounds like a consensus to me.
 
Ishmael said:
So the LIE of consensus is no longer an argument? Good, :) Because as you can see, there is no fucking consensus and there NEVER was.

Now we can dispense with that bullshit as an argument.

C'mon, Ishie.

There is virtually never absolute consensus within any scientific community. There are a variety of minority opinions on all kinds of issues, including those that have substantial degrees of consensus. The question I have is what degree of consensus opponents of policies aimed at decreasing greenhouse gases might require before they'd advocate for those policies (or at least concede the issue).

I don't know if any degree of scientific consensus at all would be satisfactory. I think a lot of these folks see scientists as egghead elitists who are posturing and getting off on the idea that they can have the ear of powerful people.

Whatcha think?
 
Last edited:
vetteman said:
Is it your contention that the document in question represents the bulk of their knowledge of that evidence?
The 8 page summary purported to be a NAS review of the science, it wasn't, it was a lie. But that's all the deniers have, lies.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top