Angeline
Poet Chick
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2002
- Posts
- 27,195
Myth means shithead ironsuited.
Now Wtf, is this number guy on about now, and wtf does it have to do with poetry?
The Affect Heuristic
I'm tempted to just drop it and say Think, but what you are doing as a writer is manipulating words to create an effect. And what you are doing as a reader (or should be) is trying to figure out how you where fooled.
excerpt
Then how about this? Yamagishi (1997) showed that subjects judged a disease as more dangerous when it was described as killing 1,286 people out of every 10,000, versus a disease that was 24.14% likely to be fatal. Apparently the mental image of a thousand dead bodies is much more alarming, compared to a single person who's more likely to survive than not.
Now how many times have you been lectured about concrete images?
but it gets worse, by extrapolation, suppose you see two poems over in New Poems, one a sonnet, one not. The easy and quick course is judge the sonnet writer as a better poet than the non sonnet writer, not necessarily true. That requires some thinking, doesn't it?
Now suppose x,y,and z, say that A is a better poet than B and x,y,and z all are good poets, is A better? Quick think - yes.
But it is not necessarily true, my first question would be are x,y, and z similar to A and B is not and that is the basis for the judgement?
Not to mention x,y, and z may actually be A (or their girlfriend). This judgement may have a degree of validity only if x,y, and z are actually quite dissimilar people.
Now do you want to write or wallow in your ignorance? To write actually requires thinking. Hard thinking.
I am reminded of a statement "this is just beautiful writing" said by a person I once respected, my question would be why? when I see another example of "this is just beautiful writing" by another that affects me more.
Think
and Think for yourself, eh?
I wouldn't underestimate the number of people who want to wallow in their ignorance. All one has to do is consider the annual poetry awards here, and how "friends" (and their alts) rush like lemmings to vote for poem x. How many people over the years have we seen come here and ask for help and then get all pissy when they get a little truth? We are an island in a sea of secretions. Who expects to find people who are working (and I mean seriously working) at their writing on a porn forum?
Anyway I like your well-illustrated point about why showing is better than telling. And I've decided to out you as an optimist for believing in all this enough to keeping saying so in spite of towering mediocrity, disinterest and--sometimes--outright hostility.