wildsweetone
i am what i am
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2002
- Posts
- 6,809
destinie21 said:WSO I'm going to express my opinion, If you're as open minded as you claim then you should find no offense here. Be mindful that this is not a personal attack though I have chosen to quote you.
I'm going to go to with the logical (logic is of course realative to the thinker) conclusion that Miss Blue Pen was not bashing the entire genre of non consent but this particular author. It was not so much his writing acumen (or lack thereof IMHO) that insighted people to rage. It was the fact that what he is talking about is clearly a brutal form of rape and he has done so strictly for erotic pleasure. The fact that an orgasm is thrown in doesn't mean that it's a simple non consent story. Who among us thinks that having your teeth knocked out or being beaten to the point where you'd be unrecognizable is erotic? It's more like chilling at least to me. You say in the above quote that lynch mobbing is something that sickens you (as it should) So imagine how nauseated you'd feel if you came across a story in the erotic couplings section about someone being graphically lynched and then an orgy thrown in at the end is just supposed to make everything just peachy. I write about rape and murder and pedophilia in essays and stories and yes to me these things are disturbing and controversial but when I write it is not to glorify or erotcize them that's what is most disturbing. In regards to AD stand on the situation he says the same thing in the reply as he said in the thread he dosen't care what I or nay Sayers any feel. Wjich is not surprising because if I felt justified in writing a lesbian story then some sent feed back saying I was sick and twisted I would say the same thing or more likely I'd say what were you doing in the lesbian section.
Anyway my real point is whether I like it or not his story is a form of free speech which I vehemently defend (nausea aside). But it belongs under extreme. I like a good Non- consent story so yes I would be mad if I came across a story like AD's there because it is (IMO) wrongly placed.
I took no offense at your posting destinie21, it was logical and basically I agree that that is what BluePen intended to do. However, when it became personal to that specific author, it became unnecessary.